First, the rationale. Buying the worst performing funds or stocks assuming a bounce must lie ahead does not work as an investment strategy – most of the time. There is one very important exception, and that is when markets or sectors fall rapidly, which tends to bring down the good with the bad. Amongst the worst performers are funds with considerable “bounceability”, and they sit alongside perpetual duds – obviously it is important to identify the former, and avoid the latter. In coming weeks we will look in more detail at how to do that.
To get this going, below are three set of data, each including a top 10 and bottom 10 since the peak of 20th February:
- Top and bottom across the totality of funds, across all sectors
- Top and bottom across the three UK stock market sectors (UK All, UK Equity Income, UK Smaller)
- Top and bottom across the three sterling bond sectors (corporate bond, high yield bond, strategic bond)
Not surprisingly, in section 1 the top funds are dominated by global bond funds. They benefitted from two elements – a falling pound and better quality government bond funds holding steady. Brazil and some energy funds feature amongst the duds. But UK-invested funds dominate the bottom 10 – look out for opportunities amongst these, but don’t jump the gun.
In section 2, UK equities, even the best funds look ugly, and the worst funds are edging towards losses of 50% in just one month. Amongst the bottom funds are some with considerable attractions once there are signs of the market bottoming.
In section 3, UK non-Government bonds, the best funds are mostly short-dated and high quality – so naturally less volatile – though only one is positive over the month. Amongst the bottom funds I again see funds I would want to buy as the market turns.
In coming weeks I will expand this discussion, and identify specific funds for a pending buy-list. Do let us know your thoughts on this.
FURTHER READING
Best and Worst Funds since Feb 20th
All
Best
Name
|
Sector
|
Fund Size(m)
|
Performance
|
Vanguard Japan Government Bond Index
|
IA Global Bonds
|
478.7
|
12.1
|
Scottish Widows International Bond
|
IA Global Bonds
|
204.9
|
12.0
|
MFS Meridian US Government Bond
|
IA Global Bonds
|
318.2
|
9.4
|
Wellington Global Total Return (UCITS)**
|
IA Targeted Absolute Return
|
135.1
|
9.4
|
GS US Mortgage Backed Securities Portfolio
|
IA Specialist
|
314.3
|
9.3
|
Standard Life Investments Global Bond
|
IA Global Bonds
|
341.2
|
9.2
|
iShares Overseas Government Bond Index (UK)
|
IA Global Bonds
|
1982.5
|
8.7
|
T. Rowe Price Global Aggregate Bond
|
IA Global Bonds
|
418.1
|
8.3
|
Wellington World Bond
|
IA Global Bonds
|
240.3
|
7.8
|
Pimco GIS Euro Short-Term
|
IA Global Bonds
|
655.4
|
7.8
|
Worst
Name
|
Sector
|
Fund Size(m)
|
Performance
|
Schroder ISF Global Energy
|
IA Global
|
189.6
|
-59.5
|
BlackRock GF World Energy
|
IA Specialist
|
919.6
|
-48.7
|
Guinness Global Energy
|
IA Global
|
67.6
|
-48.2
|
Aberforth UK Small Companies
|
IA UK Smaller Companies
|
186.8
|
-47.8
|
Merian UK Mid Cap
|
IA UK All Companies
|
1865.5
|
-47.5
|
ASI UK Unconstrained Equity
|
IA UK All Companies
|
369.8
|
-47.3
|
ASI UK Recovery Equity
|
IA UK All Companies
|
115.7
|
-46.7
|
Liontrust UK Mid Cap
|
IA UK All Companies
|
71.3
|
-46.0
|
JPM Brazil Equity
|
IA Specialist
|
66.7
|
-45.6
|
Merian UK Dynamic Equity
|
IA UK All Companies
|
291.5
|
-45.5
|
Sterling Bond Sectors
Best
Name
|
Sector
|
Fund Size(m)
|
Performance
|
Allianz Strategic Bond
|
IA Sterling Strategic Bond
|
1101.1
|
5.2
|
Waverton Sterling Bond
|
IA Sterling Strategic Bond
|
245.3
|
-0.8
|
Hermes Unconstrained Credit
|
IA Sterling Strategic Bond
|
419.8
|
-1.6
|
Rathbone High Quality Bond Fund
|
IA Sterling Corporate Bond
|
223.2
|
-2.5
|
AXA Sterling Credit Short Duration Bond
|
IA Sterling Corporate Bond
|
674.5
|
-3.0
|
M&G UK Inflation Linked Corporate Bond
|
IA Sterling Strategic Bond
|
801.3
|
-3.0
|
AXA Sterling Strategic Bond
|
IA Sterling Strategic Bond
|
156.3
|
-3.2
|
M&G Short Dated Corporate Bond
|
IA Sterling Corporate Bond
|
315.7
|
-3.3
|
Vanguard UK Short-Term Investment Grade Bond Index
|
IA Sterling Corporate Bond
|
1962.9
|
-3.3
|
Royal London Investment Grade Short Dated Credit
|
IA Sterling Corporate Bond
|
1404.8
|
-3.4
|
Worst
Name
|
Sector
|
Fund Size(m)
|
Performance
|
Legg Mason Western Asset Macro Opportunities Bond
|
IA Sterling Strategic Bond
|
5075.4
|
-21.3
|
Baillie Gifford High Yield Bond
|
IA Sterling High Yield
|
635.5
|
-21.3
|
GS Europe High Yield Bond Portfolio
|
IA Sterling High Yield
|
64.7
|
-20.8
|
Schroder High Yield Opportunities
|
IA Sterling High Yield
|
512.3
|
-20.5
|
Kames High Yield Bond
|
IA Sterling High Yield
|
446.0
|
-19.7
|
T. Rowe Price Global High Income Bond
|
IA Sterling High Yield
|
306.9
|
-19.4
|
Baring Global High Yield Bond
|
IA Sterling High Yield
|
1572.5
|
-19.1
|
Baring European High Yield Bond
|
IA Sterling High Yield
|
489.2
|
-18.9
|
Artemis High Income
|
IA Sterling Strategic Bond
|
1088.8
|
-18.6
|
L&G High Income Trust
|
IA Sterling High Yield
|
1286.5
|
-18.2
|
UK Equity Sectors
Best
Name
|
Sector
|
Fund Size(m)
|
Performance
|
Ardevora UK Equity
|
IA UK All Companies
|
142.3
|
-22.7
|
Lindsell Train LF Lindsell Train UK Equity
|
IA UK All Companies
|
5946.4
|
-25.6
|
LF Miton UK Multi Cap Income
|
IA UK Equity Income
|
907.7
|
-25.6
|
Aviva Inv UK Equity MoM 1
|
IA UK All Companies
|
274.7
|
-25.7
|
Investec UK Equity Income
|
IA UK All Companies
|
96.3
|
-25.7
|
Troy Asset Management Ltd Trojan Income
|
IA UK Equity Income
|
3150.2
|
-25.9
|
TB Evenlode Income
|
IA UK All Companies
|
3757.0
|
-26.6
|
Royal London Sustainable Leaders Trust
|
IA UK All Companies
|
891.9
|
-26.7
|
Virgin UK Index Tracking
|
IA UK All Companies
|
2916.8
|
-26.7
|
JOHCM UK Opportunities
|
IA UK All Companies
|
368.5
|
-27.0
|
Worst
Name
|
Sector
|
Fund Size(m)
|
Performance
|
Aberforth UK Small Companies
|
IA UK Smaller Companies
|
186.8
|
-47.8
|
Merian UK Mid Cap
|
IA UK All Companies
|
1865.5
|
-47.5
|
ASI UK Unconstrained Equity
|
IA UK All Companies
|
369.8
|
-47.3
|
ASI UK Recovery Equity
|
IA UK All Companies
|
115.7
|
-46.7
|
Liontrust UK Mid Cap
|
IA UK All Companies
|
71.3
|
-46.0
|
Merian UK Dynamic Equity
|
IA UK All Companies
|
291.5
|
-45.5
|
Jupiter UK Growth
|
IA UK All Companies
|
444.3
|
-45.2
|
Aviva Inv UK Listed Equity High Alpha
|
IA UK All Companies
|
207.9
|
-45.1
|
Schroder UK Mid 250
|
IA UK All Companies
|
621.0
|
-44.8
|
Aviva Inv UK Listed Equity Unconstrained**
|
IA UK All Companies
|
176.7
|
-44.4
|